|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
The Skull and the Skeleton |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Read the real story of the Earhart Loss at www.AmeliaEarhartBook.com |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
| According to
a Discovery Chanel reporter and anthropologist Karen
Burns :"The evidence is plentiful -- but not conclusive yet
-- to support the hypothesis that Amelia landed and died on the island
of Nikumaroro," forensic anthropologist Karen Ramey Burns told
Discovery News. The author of a book on Earhart, Burns believes that the
strongest of the amassed evidence comes from the report related to the
partial skeleton found by Gallagher (British Colonial Service officer Gerald
Gallagher). "The skeleton was found to be consistent in
appearance with females of European descent in the United States today,
and the stature was consistent with that of Amelia Earhart," said
Burns. However, the findings dispute the evidence as being
"plentiful" and "amassed."
The truth of the matter is the evidence is exceptionally dubious and has
never been traced to Amelia Earhart.The bones were shipped to a Dr. D.
W. Hoodless in Suva, Fiji, to see if he could make a basic
identification. Hoodless had 13 bones to work with, including the skull
and some long bones from the legs and arms. His conclusion was that the
bones belonged not only to a European, but a European male who was about
5'6" — significantly shorter than Earhart who was 5'9." The
documents say nothing about her navigator Fred Noonan. If the bones were
thrown out in the trash how did Anthropologist Burns come to the
conclusion that the bones were consistent with the size of a
European female? The Hoodless commentary appears to be the most accurate
as he had the actual bones there for observation.
Without the evidence of a Caldwell Luc operation on the skull, the whole matter is closed. Amelia Earhart suffered from a chronic sinsitus condition. Surgeons who did a bilateral Caldwell Luc operation on AE in July 1935 drilled two holes in the upper bone of the skull (maxima) to relieve pressure in her continuing sinus problem. These two holes would still be quite visible. There is no comment in any of the reports offered by Hoodless that the skull contained evidence of the Caldwell Luc operation. The Western Pacific High Commission (WPHC), headed by Sir Harry Luke, who was also the Governor of Fiji, ordered the examination of the skeletal remains and the other materials by various authorities. Since forensic science has advanced so much in the last sixty years, TIGHAR wanted to test DNA from the skeleton and determine to a high degree of certitude whether or not the bones were those of Amelia Earhart. However, the problem is since Dr. Hoodless had said the bones could not possibly belong to Earhart it is possible that any of these men may have said in effect, “Oh, just get rid of that stuff. I can’t be bothered with it.” Consequently, the bones have disappeared and no one knows of their whereabouts. The box of bones and the box with the shoe parts and corks and the sextants box were just junk they supposed, and they were trashed. If this is what happened in fact took place the evidence is gone. Under such circumstances it would be very hard to build any type of a scientific case that the bones that were found by Gerald Gallagher were the last remain of Amelia Earhart. In 1960, the late Floyd Kilts, a retired Coast Guardsman, gave an interview to the San Diego, California Tribune. His speculation was based on what he said he had been told by one of the colonists while Kilts was helping dismantle a Loran station on Nikumaroro in 1946. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
Mr. Kilts' contention that
Amelia Earhart's skeleton was found in 1938 on Earhart
DNA Research Update March
1, 2011Cecil M. Lewis, Jr., Ph.D.Molecular Anthropology
LaboratoriesUniversity of Oklahoma, Norman, OK At the request of The International
Group for Historic Aircraft Recovery (TIGHAR), University of Oklahoma
researchers have been evaluating a bone fragment excavated from an
archaeological site on Nikumaroro (formerly Gardner Island). TIGHAR is
testing the hypothesis that Amelia Earhart died as a castaway on the
uninhabited Pacific atoll. The bone fragment’s structure and the
context in which it was found have led TIGHAR to wonder if it might be
part of a human finger. TIGHAR also asked OU researchers to evaluate
small clumps of material recovered from the same archaeological site to
determine whether they might be human fecal matter. The Bone Fragment: We were not able to retrieve sufficient DNA from the bone sample to be able to provide any definitive statements on the bone’s origin.The bone fragment was very small, approximately one gram of material. Following appropriate ancient DNA protocols, we attempted to extract DNA from .25 grams of the material. We used a real time Polymerase Chain Reaction method (real time PCR or rtPCR) to detect human mitochondrial DNA in the extract. Two of these rtPCRs provided a positive result. However, during quality control protocols, we were unable to repeat this result with additional rtPCRs. This suggests that either 1) the initial detection of human DNA was attributed to a sporadic DNA contamination event, and in reality, there was no usable human DNA preserved in the extract, 2) there was human DNA in the extract, but it was too little, or of too poor of quality, to consistently analyze, 3) DNA in the bone was non-human. A second DNA extraction also failed to provide positive results for human DNA. Because the bone is clearly from an animal, human or otherwise, additional PCRs were used to detect animal DNA more generally. These PCRs provided no positive results. The fact that these PCRs were unsuccessful suggest that either 1) there is no animal DNA in the bone, 2) there was animal DNA in the extract, but it was too little, or of too poor of quality, to reliably analyze, 3) the PCR design was ineffective for targeting the particular animal. Approximately 0.5 grams of bone material remained after our study. For posterity, we have decided to preserve this remaining bone. Genome technologies are developing at a rapid pace. To what extent ancient DNA research will benefit from these developments remains to be seen. Nevertheless, there is reason for optimism that some day in the near future, less destructive, and more sensitive genomic methods will be able to resolve the bone’s origin. For now, the question of whether the bone is human must remain unanswered. Reference...http://tighar.org/Projects/Earhart/Archives/Research/Bulletins/59_DNAResearch/lewisstatement.pdf |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Extensive official British government records confirm the discovery in 1940 of the partial skeleton of a castaway who perished while attempting to survive on Nikumaroro sometime prior to the island's settlement in 1939. The remains of a fire, dead birds and a turtle were present. With the bones were found a sextant box bearing a stenciled number that is similar to a number written on a sextant box known to have belonged to Fred Noonan, Amelia Earhart's navigator. The remains of a woman's shoe and a man's shoe were also found at the site. Also at the site were "corks with brass chains" thought to have been from a small cask which may have come from the Norwich City, a wrecked freighter off the coast of Gardner Island. A Benedictine bottle found with the remains may have also been part of the cache. The bones were from one of the lost crewman. The woman's shoe possibly came from an American woman Laxton had an American woman with him on Niku in 1949. The forgotten Sextant box could have been from the drunken navigator of the Norwich City affectionately named Mad Mac McGregor. Some of the "discoveries" have been so comical that, in 1992, the Detroit News ran the above cartoon. TIGHAR, the instigator of these stories, assumes everything is related, and they framed it all in Earhart survival stories. More recently, a TIGHAR research expedition came back with supposedly dried human feces off the beach at Nikumaroro, on the premises that Amelia Earhart left a deposit to dry in the sun oblivious to over 70 years of tropical storms and erosion. They are searching the specimen for Mitochondrial DNA |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Amelia Earhart's Shoes |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Read the real story of the Earhart Loss at www.AmeliaEarhartBook.com |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
P.B. Laxton , a sort of explorer-naturalist, visited Nikumroro
circa 1949 as part of the Phoenix island surveys. He wrote in the
"Jo urnal of the Polynesian Society," a South Pacific
publication, of his exploration on Nikumaroro. It is a very
comprehensive history of Niku begining with the Arundel plantation thru
the WW 2 activities. They found a house built by a settler, Jack Kima.
Off the southern end of the house there was the bathroom, lavatory and
washbasin. "An American lady who had visted with us earlier when
the house had been unoccupied for some time, had proceeded to the
lavatory, which is of the "thunder-box" variey, and found it
full of dynamite. She later washed in the neat and impressive handbasin..." |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
The Sextant Box |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Read the real story of the Earhart Loss at www.AmeliaEarhartBook.com |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
The sextant box discovered by Gerald Gallagher in the summer of 1940 on
Niku was
described as being "old fashioned," and it had the number "3500"
stenciled on it and another number 1542. He thought the box had been painted over with black enamel.
The actual sextant was never found. No specific descriptions
of the dimension or the internal configurations were provided. Gallagher, thinking they could be linked to Earhart or
a castaway, sent the box to Australian aerial navigator Harold Gatty in Fiji.
Gatty wrote that the box was "English," old, and "judged that it
was used merely as a receptacle" adding he didn't think "it could not in any circumstances have been a sextant box used in
trans-Pacific navigation." This conclusion of course would eliminate any kind of
aerial navigation sextant used by Noonan, and thus this artifact didn't support
an Earhart landing at Nikumaroro. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
The Dado, Scrap Aluminum, and Pleixglas |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Read the real story of the Earhart Loss at www.AmeliaEarhartBook.com |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
| The TIGHAR group takes particular pride in establishing a piece of scrap aluminum, a dado (liner between the floor and the sides of the fuselage of a Lockheed Electra), and a scrap of plexiglas as being parts that came from the Earhart airplane. They seem to fit a Lockheed Electra design. However, the same as the sextant box, none of these items have been traced to the Earhart airplane. There is no way to identify the source of the findings. It is impossible to prove these airplane parts came from Earhart's Electra. There are no serial numbers or other markings on the parts. It is hard to believe that an Electra could crash on a remote Pacific reef, and the local natives only salvaged pieces of floor liner, or scraps of aluminum or one very small piece plexiglas. These few parts would have been impossible to remove unless the airplane was broken up in a crash or it had been sent to a salvage yard. This would seem to suggest that the dados were removed from a section of wreckage rather than from an intact aircraft. Such being the case, the occupants of the airplane would have probably been killed or severely injured if this airplane crashed on a section of reef at Gardner Island as TIGHAR contends. Complicating the problems associated with artifacts at Gardner Island is that local natives may have hauled the foregoing items in from scrap yards in the neighboring islands. The Dados would have been riveted, glued, or installed with metal screws. It is not the type of installation natives of the Phoenix Islands would have been adept at uninstalling. Not one single piece of aluminum, or floor liners (Dados), or plexiglass that has been found and has been linked to Earhart's Electra. The Electra was a well known airline transport in its day. The Department of Aviation in New Zealand in May 1965 has records of eight Lockheed Electras flying in the area of the Central Pacific. These airplanes either crashed or lost their airworthiness registration certificates. What was left of the airplanes were broken up and sent to scrap yards. Canton Island in the Phoenix Island group and close to Gardner Island had an operating airfield. It became a stopover point for the Navy Air Transport Service flights to Australia and New Zealand as well as a staging point for attacks on the Gilbert Islands held by Japan during World War II In November 1946, Pan Am resumed service to Australia and New Zealand via Canton with Douglas DC-4 aircraft. British Commonwealth Pacific Airlines, Australia's first trans-Pacific airline, used the island as a stopover on the way to Hawaii, flying luxurious DC-6Bs on the Sydney to Vancouver BC, Canada route .Quantas took over this service shortly thereafter, after BCPA went out of business. Canadian Pacific Airlines used the island as well. | |||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Lockheed
test pilot Marshall Headle, Amelia Earhart, and technical adviser Paul
Mantz
In the background is a Lockheed Model 10A sold to Guinea Airways
and registered VH-UXI |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
| The Trec to Gardner Island | |||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Read the real story of the Earhart Loss at www.AmeliaEarhartBook.com |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
The TIGHAR expeditions to Gardner Island started in September 1989. Some 97 years earlier in May 1892, the island was claimed by England during a call by a British sailing ship. Almost immediately a license was granted to Pacific entrepreneur John T.Arundel for planting coconuts. Twenty nine islanders were settled there and some structures with corrugated iron roofs were constructed; however, because there was no fresh water supply a severe drought caused the project to fail. The island remain uninhabited until 1938. On November 29, 1929, the SS Norwich City, a large British freighter with a crew of thirty-five men ran aground on the reef at the island's northwest corner during a storm. There were at least eight fatalities. The remaining crew camped near collapsed structures from the Arundel project and were rescued after surviving several days on the island. On December1, 1938, members of the British Pacific Islands Survey Expedition led by E.W. Lee arrived to evaluate the island as a possible location for either seaplane landings or as an airfield. Twenty days later more British officials arrived with 20 Gilbert islanders to settle the atoll. All of this took place within eighteen months after the Earhart disappearance on July 2, 1937. By June 1939, a few wells had been successfully established and there were 58 islanders on Gardner. During this period of time, there were no reported findings of Earhart artifacts including bones or airplane parts. The British colonial officer, Gerald Gallagher, established a headquarters of the Phoenix Islands Settlement Scheme in the village located on the island's western end, on the south side of the largest entrance to the lagoon. Wide coral-gravel streets and a parade ground were laid out and important structures included a thatched administration house, a wood-frame cooperative store, and a radio shack. Gallagher died and was buried on the island in 1941. During World War II from 1944 through 1945 the US Coast Guard operated a navigational Loran station with 25 crewmen on the southeastern tip of Gardner, installing one Quonset hut and some smaller structures. The island's population reached a high of approximately 100 by the mid-1950s. However, by the early 1960s, periodic drought and an unstable freshwater lens had thwarted the struggling colony. Its residents were evacuated to the Solomon Islands by the British in 1963 and by 1965 Gardner was officially uninhabited.
Today
on Gardner Island, what was once a forest is now
dense underbrush. Orderly coconut plantations have become jungles. Houses
and administrative buildings have come and gone like the people who built
them. The wreck of the
Norwich City has steadily deteriorated and has scattered wreckage over
the reefs. |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Where's the Proof? |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Read the real story of the Earhart Loss at www.AmeliaEarhartBook.com |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
| The truth of the matter is there is no proof of Earhart crashing and perishing on Gardner Island. The TIGHAR trips to Nikumaroro have not yielded any results that the research community has been willing to accept. In fact it has turned into some type of a "charade" of unwarranted claims. However, that doesn't stop TIGHAR from making trips to Gardner Island looking for more evidence, whatever it is they expect to find. If nothing else it helps to keep Amelia Earhart in the news. As long as the Discovery Channel and unknowing reporters can put out press releases, it keeps the pot cooking for those who carry the torch for Gardner Island. Unfortunately, very little of it seems to make any sense. After all has been said and done, without TIGHAR a great deal of information about the Earhart disappearance would not have been available... including the proof that Earhart did not crash at Gardner Island which, if you dig below the surface on the TIGHAR website, it becomes readily apparent such does indeed seem to be the case. Richard Pyle at the Associated Press exclaimed he didn't care what the proof revealed, he wanted the physical evidence of the Earhart loss. That's what makes headlines to his way of thinking. Whether the proof made any sense or not was besides the point. In certain respects the TIGHAR quest for evidence at Gardner Island took a measure of desperation when the group came back with a piece of supposedly hardened human feces off the beach. Evidence? Over seventy years later, the investigation seems to be sliding downhill | |||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Sextant... Never found |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Sextant Box... Found but the whereabouts is now unknown (believed to have been thrown out in the trash) |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Amelia Earhart's Shoes... The wrong size |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Dado (Floor Liners)... Scraps from a Pacific scrapyard |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Aluminum Parts... Scraps with no way of identifying the parts as coming from Earhart's Electra |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Plexiglass... One scrap from an airplane crash with no way to identify this piece as coming from Earhart' Electra |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Bones from a Skeleton... Identity unknown (believed to have been a European male by a Doctor who examined the skeleton; thereafter, the bones were discarded and thrown out in the trash |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
| Evidence that Amelia Earhart Crashed and Sank at Howland Island Has Also Been Proven False !! | |||||||||||||||||||||||
|
The Earhart airplane did not crash and sink at Howland Island !! |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Waitt Industries just finished a detailed underwater
search for Earhart's Electra in the vicinity of Howland Island.
This search combined with the Nauticos search several years proves
beyond any question Earhart did not crash in the sea at Howland
irrespective of the movie "Amelia" and the two TV
specials several years ago. The Waitt Industries search
was very thorough and had no budget limitations. This search also
negates the Elgen Long book and the Susan Butler which claim
Earhart crashed and sank at Howland Island. For the real story of
the Earhart loss read "The Lost Flight of Amelia
Earhart" available on this website.
SAN DIEGO, Jan. 20 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- The Waitt Institute for Discovery (http://wid.waittinstitute.org), a non-profit research organization established by Ted Waitt, founder and former Chairman of Gateway, Inc., has launched its new Search for Amelia Web site (http://searchforamelia.org). Created to publish the full results from the Institute's 2009 search for Amelia Earhart's Lockheed Electra, the site is also a gateway for information on Earhart's life and legacy. Earhart and her navigator, Fred Noonan, disappeared without a trace near Howland Island in the Pacific during Amelia's 1937 attempt to fly around the world. The Waitt Institute's recent expedition to find Earhart's plane, known as CATALYST 2, was a collaboration with Harbor Branch Oceanographic Institute (HBOI) and Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (WHOI). The area surveyed was based on extensive research completed by a team of experienced air accident investigators. The initial search area was a 2,500-square-mile box -- an area equivalent to the state of Delaware -- located off the western shores of Howland Island. The Research Report is available on the site. The search area was 1,100 miles, approximately four days travel for HBOI's Research Vessel Seward Johnson, north of our base of operations in Pago Pago, American Samoa. The Research Report is available on the site. The search area was 1,100 miles, approximately four days travel for HBOI's Research Vessel Seward Johnson, north of our base of operations in Pago Pago, American Samoa. The mission covered 7,000 linear miles of ocean floor, generating a 2,200-square-mile mosaic, at an average depth of 5,200 meters using a pair of cutting-edge REMUS 6000 Autonomous Underwater Vehicles (AUVs). The most sophisticated deep-sea search vehicles available today, these AUVs are pre-programmed to operate independently once released from the support ship. When the vehicles reach their planned depth, about three miles beneath the surface, they begin flying over the ocean bottom at an average speed of 3.5 knots using side scan sonar to capture a swath of sonar imagery at least 1,200 meters. The vehicles feature a pencil-beam automatic sonar collision-avoidance system to allow them to operate in rugged underwater terrain. They also have an exceptional degree of navigational accuracy. Once a target is found in the sonar data, the vehicles are then re-programmed to return to the coordinates of the target, do a higher resolution sonar pass deeper and closer to the object, and then a conduct a high resolution photo shoot of the object. Nimble and highly efficient, the Waitt Institute's AUVs are truly revolutionary in the world of underwater search. Waitt said, "Our AUVs were able to efficiently search a massive area and then re-acquire, re-image and clearly photograph very small targets including a pipe, a chain, rock formations, a metal drum and even a six-inch-wide cable, well over three miles below the ocean's surface. We've mapped geology no one has ever seen, and we now know far more about what lies beneath the waves in the North Pacific. Waitt said, "Our AUVs were able to efficiently search a massive area and then re-acquire, re-image and clearly photograph very small targets including a pipe, a chain, rock formations, a metal drum and even a six-inch-wide cable, well over three miles below the ocean's surface. We've mapped geology no one has ever seen, and we now know far more about what lies beneath the waves in the North Pacific today than we did yesterday. This work will hopefully not only benefit explorers, but also oceanographers, geologists, biologists and others in the science community." |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Contrary
to the Elgen Long book the only thing Waitt Industries found that was
recognizable was a pipe and a metal barrel plus assorted rock formations
resting on the ocean floor....
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|